This PR implements second part of #2 for Boost.Beast agent.

To disambiguate calls to API methods without real arguments (like log_out()) those methods now don't have empty args param. Technically, it is a breaking change, but only for users, who explicitly pass empty args to those methods (maybe, nobody).

I made this PR for personal project, but hope it will be helpful. :)

How about adding fully asynchronous requests? This is something that lacks in https://github.com/reo7sp/tgbot-cpp and https://github.com/slowriot/libtelegram.

Problem:

1. CPR allows calling synchronous libcurl from std::async, which isn't fully asynchronous.
2. boost::beast allows async requests, however coroutines may not be needed.

Solution:

1. Asynchronous libcurl looks like a good addition to the backend bundles - https://curl.se/libcurl/c/libcurl-multi.html;
2. Also boost beast without coroutines can be adopted here - https://www.boost.org/doc/libs/1_76_0/libs/beast/example/http/client/async/http_client_async.cpp

The banana library already contains a well-structured serialization solution for telegram types - deser.hpp, meta.hpp, core.cpp and serialization.hpp, but the problem is with extensibility.

If a client uses the banana library and needs a serialization of custom types for some other non-telegram purposes, one needs to reimplement the whole serialization/deserialization again because of the banana design.

But what I noticed to be extremely beneficial is the ability to reuse and specify serializer behavior with custom-created types. Below I added the example of the desired functionality.

The client only creates the reflector stuff and reuses or extends(in terms of creating new struct serializer<T>:) logic of the banana library.

struct Temp {
	int64_t x, y;
	double z;
};
namespace banana {
	namespace meta {
		template <>
		struct reflector<Temp> {
			template <class F>
			static void for_each_field(F&& f) {
				f(string_view_t("x"), &Temp::x);
				f(string_view_t("y"), &Temp::y);
				f(string_view_t("z"), &Temp::z);
			}
		};
		template <>
		constexpr bool is_reflectable_v<Temp> = true;
		template <>
		constexpr string_view_t name_of<Temp>("Temp");
	}
	namespace deser {
		template optional_t<string_t> serialize<Temp>(Temp value);
	}
}

I agree that because of the template-based serialization, it's not easy to do. However, since you referred to some upcoming changes on the JSON-related part in another issue, I'd like this one to be taken into consideration as well. P. S. I mentioned only the serialization part here for simplicity but implied deserialization as well.

Let me know your thoughts here...

Timeout set before async_write was not reset before async_read, so it limited maximum long-poll timeout to 30 seconds. Telegram long-polling seems to support timeout for up to 50 seconds, so I set async_read timeout to 60 seconds.

Compiling the test program : #include <banana/api.hpp> #include <banana/agent/cpr.hpp>

#include

static_assert(std::is_same_v<banana::api_result<banana::api::message_t, banana::agent::cpr_async>, std::futurebanana::api::message_t>);

int main(int argc, const char** argv) { if (argc < 3) { std::cout << "usage: " << (argc > 0 ? argv[0] : "./self") << " token target [name] [os]\n"; return 2; }

const std::string token = argv[1]; const std::string target = argv[2]; const std::string name = argc > 3 ? argv[3] : ""; const std::string os = argc > 4 ? argv[4] : "";

const std::string message_text = "Hello from " + name + " at " + os + "!";

try { banana::agent::cpr_async agent(token);

std::cout << "bot name: " << banana::api::get_me(agent).get().username.value() << "\n";
std::cout << "message sent: " << banana::api::send_message(agent, { target, message_text }).get().message_id << "\n";

} catch (std::exception& e) { std::cout << "exception while running " << name << ": " << e.what() << "\n"; return 1; } }

with Microsoft Visual Studio Community 2019 Version 16.9.6, gives me the following erros :

Severity Code Description Project File Line Suppression State Error (active) E0304 no instance of function template "banana::api::send_message" matches the argument list TesteBanana F:\downloads\banana-master_BUILD_DIR\TesteBanana\teste1.cpp 27 Severity Code Description Project File Line Suppression State Error LNK2019 unresolved external symbol "public: __cdecl banana::agent::basic_cpr_monadic::basic_cpr_monadic(class std::basic_string<char,struct std::char_traits,class std::allocator >)" ([email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected][email protected][email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@@z) referenced in function "public: __cdecl banana::agent::meta::unwrap_blocking::unwrap_blocking(class std::basic_string<char,struct std::char_traits,class std::allocator >)" ([email protected][email protected]@[email protected]@@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected][email protected][email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@@z) TesteBanana F:\downloads\banana-master_BUILD_DIR\TesteBanana\teste1.obj 1

Compiling the test program :

#include <banana/api.hpp>
#include <banana/agent/cpr.hpp>

#include <iostream>

static_assert(std::is_same_v<banana::api_result<banana::api::message_t, banana::agent::cpr_async>, std::future<banana::api::message_t>>);

int main(int argc, const char** argv) {
    if (argc < 3) {
        std::cout << "usage: " << (argc > 0 ? argv[0] : "./self") << " token target [name] [os]\n";
        return 2;
    }

    const std::string token  = argv[1];
    const std::string target = argv[2];
    const std::string name   = argc > 3 ? argv[3] : "<unknown>";
    const std::string os     = argc > 4 ? argv[4] : "<unknown>";

    const std::string message_text = "Hello from " + name + " at " + os + "!";

    try {
        banana::agent::cpr_async agent(token);

        std::cout << "bot name: " << banana::api::get_me(agent).get().username.value() << "\n";
        std::cout << "message sent: " << banana::api::send_message(agent, { target, message_text }).get().message_id << "\n";
    }
    catch (std::exception& e) {
        std::cout << "exception while running " << name << ": " << e.what() << "\n";
        return 1;
    }
}

with Microsoft Visual Studio Community 2019 Version 16.9.6, gives me the following erros :

Severity	Code	Description	Project	File	Line	Suppression State
Error (active)	E0304	no instance of function template "banana::api::send_message" matches the argument list	TesteBanana	F:\downloads\banana-master\_BUILD_DIR\TesteBanana\teste1.cpp	27	
Severity	Code	Description	Project	File	Line	Suppression State
Error	LNK2019	unresolved external symbol "public: __cdecl banana::agent::basic_cpr_monadic::basic_cpr_monadic(class std::basic_string<char,struct std::char_traits<char>,class std::allocator<char> >)" ([email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected][email protected][email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@@Z) referenced in function "public: __cdecl banana::agent::meta::unwrap_blocking<class banana::agent::basic_cpr_monadic>::unwrap_blocking<class banana::agent::basic_cpr_monadic>(class std::basic_string<char,struct std::char_traits<char>,class std::allocator<char> >)" ([email protected][email protected]@[email protected]@@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected][email protected][email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@@Z)	TesteBanana	F:\downloads\banana-master\_BUILD_DIR\TesteBanana\teste1.obj	1	

Is there any functionality from the Telegram API or design-based yet not supported/planned/in progress?

If so, it might be beneficial to point it out explicitly in the README.md/milestones - therefore, potential customers can track the progress and developers contribute.

There is a problem when building the project with MSVC: C1128: number of sections exceeded object file format limit: compile with /bigobj.

I tried compiling with beast connector, and that's the error for beast.cpp.

Setting this option would restrict the number of linkers that can consume the resulting object files - maybe, it worth decoupling the file into several ones?

Replace low-quality html2json.py with better (probably external) alternative to keep API up-to-date. Possible options:

• https://github.com/ark0f/tg-bot-api (https://ark0f.github.io/tg-bot-api/custom.json) - supports Bot API 5.3, good quality, markdown style comments

Speaking of the code snippet beast.cpp,

// Gracefully close the socket
boost::beast::error_code ec;
stream.shutdown(ec);

what is the reason for ignoring the socket error closing error?

According to the htt_client_sync_example from the boost::beast developers, that error is supposed to be treated as such. While I agree, the error there isn't important according to the https://github.com/boostorg/beast/issues/824, explicit comment pointing that out might be useful.

Hi, i would really like to use this library because it has so little dependencies, but i can't get it to work.

None of the examples seem to work, neither the one from the readme, nor the ones in the examples folder. They all include the banana/agent/default.hpp or something similar, but they don't exist. Only banana/agent/any.hpp exists but that doesn't work on its own. They kinda do exist in the source folder, is that a mistake? Or are the examples horribly out of date?

It would be really helpful if you could provide a working example for the latest version. I just want to send a message, that's it. I am on Windows.

Thank you in advance, Florian

Just for now banana doesn't support sending files (see InputFile API section). We need a solution that is:

• Optional - do not require every agent to support file uploading
• Simple - single customization point for every to-be-supported agent (like agent::request<T>, but for file uploading)
• Generic - support both blocking, async and coroutine-based agents
• Isolated - do not modify existing API methods

The purpose of this issue is to create a bundle based on the https://github.com/yhirose/cpp-httplib.

Overall, this is a great library similar to CPR but supports both clients, server connections and doesn't depend on the libcurl. Server-related or any other unused code can be easily deleted since the library is a one-header file only.

Why CPP-httlib?

1. Thread-safe access;
2. SSL, proxy, error-codes, timeout;
3. Extensive support and usage - 5.1k stars;
4. One-header only;

Here are some drawbacks of such addition:

1. Non-blocking requests aren't supported by default, but there exists a solution mentioned here(https://github.com/rtrahan504/cpp-httplib/tree/nonblocking_server) and here(https://github.com/yhirose/cpp-httplib/issues/875), which allows them. Adding blocking-only requests might be a good start.
2. Overkill for telegram and banana purposes. Are you thinking of extending the existing WinAPI connector instead? Answering that, we don't need to use all the CPP-httplib in full, but simply extract the minimum needed for SSL, proxy, thread-safety, error-codes, timeouts until a custom replacement solution is available.
3. C++11 - there is a cpp17 branch in the dev state - https://github.com/yhirose/cpp-httplib/tree/cpp17.

I am not claiming this is necessary, just thinking loudly and pointing out to such a library...

int main(int argc, char** argv) {
    using namespace banana::connector;
    beast_blocking_monadic connector("<TG_BOT_TOKEN>")
    auto resp = banana::api::send_message(connector, { /* .chat_id = */ "@smertig", /* .text = */ "Hello, world!" });
    if (!resp) {
        cerr << string(resp.error()) << "\n"; // providing string-based error message
        switch(ErrorCode(resp.error()) { // additional error-treatment based on the codes
            case ErrorCode::ConnectionTimeout: ...
            case ErrorCode::Deserialization: ...
            case ErrorCode::RuntimeError: …
            case ErrorCode::Serialization: ...
            case ErrorCode::ConnectionWrite: ...
            case ErrorCode::SSL*: ...
        }
    }
}

Let's say we want to retry the request for particular failure reasons only or treat the errors differently based on the underlying reason - there is no way to do that at the moment because of string-based errors.

From the client-side, it's substantial to distinguish between connection(SSL, read, write, bind, lookup, timeout) based errors and serialization/deserialization, std::errors,ok =false, other C++ errors.

This issue proposes either of two options:

1. Creating common failure error codes for all the bundles based on HTTP, libcurl, whatever, allow setting them within the connectors and save as an edition in struct error_t class. Those error values may not be present, we can store ErrorCode::Unknown by default, but if additional error parsing is available by the bundle - see the CPR as an example, the banana will provide it to the end-user. You are already converting the error codes to string in cpr.cpp, so in theory, it's possible to preserve error codes as well.

2. Storing different error-code values based on the chosen connector - this will allow more sophisticated error treatment but might break the idea of the common template-based interface. I would prefer the option which provides more detailed error treatment - if the error codes among bundles can't be kept consistent, so be it.

Let me know your thoughts here...

There are various reasons when sending requests are gonna fail - the idea of this suggestion is allowing low-level retries/timeouts for HTTP requests if possible on the bundle. Also, I noticed, that SSL is enabled in boost::beast by default, though disabled in CPR (the CPR allows it) - uniform behavior is expected, in my opinion. Enabling/disabling SSL configurations will be a valuable addition.

When creating the connector, one can specify those connection parameters. connector::cpr_blocking_monadic connector(token); // for simple usage as it's now connector::cpr_blocking_monadic connector(config); // here config is CPR-related class, which allows advanced configuring.

Looks like httplib, CPR already supports timeouts - https://github.com/yhirose/cpp-httplib, https://github.com/whoshuu/cpr; in boost/beast you are setting 30 seconds as constants. Regarding retries, one might say the programmer should handle it on the upper level. Indeed one can, but won't it create a performance overhead because of the serialization/deserialization taking place?

Problem: My point is there are a lot of cases where the returned by telegram response isn't fully needed - therefore, avoiding its deserialization or deserializing upon the request can speed up the process significantly.

For example, consider sending the message to some chat with auto resp = api::send_message(connector, args);, where API can return the following JSON - {"ok":true,"result":{"message_id":1197,"from":{"id":..,"is_bot":true,"first_name":"Fun Bot","username":"..."},"chat":{"id":..,"title":"simulation","type":"supergroup"},"date":1623916598,"text":"Hello, world!"}}

What banana does, is deserializing the whole returned JSON into message_t, which is relatively slow, because, in fact, only "ok": true, "result":{} can be significant for the end client.

Solution: My suggestion here is to do partial deserialization of the ok, result fields - similarly to what we can see in the extract_api_result, but parsing certain depth only and postpone the whole deserialization:

Provide a way to receive status-only responses or do lazy-like deserialization;

auto ok_resp = api::send_message(connector, args, /*lazy=*/true); // by default, lazy = false
if (!ok_resp) { // ok = false or error happened }
else {
    cout << string(ok_resp) << "\n"; // json response printed
    process(*ok_resp); // here the whole deserialization happens - we might not even call this
}

Let me know your thoughts about such a proposal.